Tom Reilly (Braff) and his wife Sofia (Peet) are in for some major changes now that they have a newborn. When Sofia decides to be a stay-at-home mom all that changes. Tom moves the family to Ohio to work for his father-in-law (Grodin). His boss, Chip (Bateman), happens to still carry a torch for Sofia from their high school days. Chip will stop at nothing to see Tom defeated which enlightens his manhood challenged (by a surprisingly large adversary) and he's watching his family slip away.